1024x500 1

2024 Valentine’s Day Jewelry Gift Guide

The annual day of romance is here, and with it can come big gift expectations. But don’t worry, at James Allen we have you covered for Valentine’s Day. No matter your budget or the recipient, we’ve got the glitz to make this their favorite holiday.

Valentine’s Day Jewelry

James Allen Valentine’s Day Sale

It’s corny, it’s romantic, and sometimes it feels like too much! After all, wasn’t it just the holiday season yesterday? Don’t worry, whether you love this day of love or pray you don’t see one more box of candy, our annual Valentine’s Day sale will help you get the perfect gift. 

14K Yellow Gold Four Prong Diamond Tennis Bracelet (2 CTW - H-I / SI1-SI2)
18K White Gold South Sea Cultured Pearl And Diamond Earrings

Valentine’s Jewelry

No matter if you’re shopping for yourself, the one that holds your heart, or you want to make your entire girl gang shine, shopping for Valentine’s jewelry can be a challenge. But never fear! We’ve got glitz in every budget so that everyone on your list can sparkle from head to toe.

Gifts Under $200

Sticking to a budget does NOT mean compromising on quality and style when you shop with James Allen. Choose from earrings, bracelets, rings, and more! There’s no need for Cupid when you have options like this!

14K Yellow Gold Script Love Ring
14K Yellow Gold White Enamel Bead Bracelet

Our fine jewelry collection has multiple, beautiful pieces created by expert craftsmen, from glorious gold pieces to precious pearls, we’ve got something to make everyone shine.

Gifts Under $500

Who doesn’t love diamonds? Diamonds are always on trend and luckily, we’ve got multiple pieces to make everyone dazzle. Go for a perfect pair of diamond studs, a blingy bracelet, or select one of our many diamond necklaces.

14K White Gold Four Prong Round Brilliant Lab Created Diamond Stud Earrings (0.25 CTW - F-G / VS2-SI1)
14K White Gold Diamond Infinity Necklace

We’ve got everything from classic pieces to modern designs, ensuring there’s something to suit everyone’s style. These are some of our faves but the best gift is the one that comes from your heart.

Splurge! Gifts Under $1,000

Are you in the mood to splurge? We’re here for it! When your budget is capped at $1,000 the options seem endless. We were barely able to choose a few favorites to show you!

14K Yellow Gold Rainbow Bar Bracelet By Brevani
14K White Gold Inside Out Round Hoops, 1/2 Inch Diameter (0.25 Ctw.)

Our collection features multiple pieces with gorgeous gemstones, dazzling diamonds, precious pearls, and yummy metals.  This budget allows you to up the dazzle and splurge on that luxurious piece you’ve had your eye on.

Investment Pieces – Gifts Under $5,000

If you’re ready to invest in the ultimate luxury and are looking for timeless pieces that will never go out of style, look no further! From eternally elegant tennis bracelets to opulent diamond and pearl earrings that future generations are sure to praise, we’ve got a myriad of options for you.

18K White Gold South Sea Cultured Pearl And Diamond Earrings
14K Yellow Gold Four Prong Diamond Tennis Bracelet (2 CTW - H-I / SI1-SI2)

When making such an investment it is important to avoid trends in favor of time-honored styles. Many experts recommend when investing in jewelry, to choose pieces featuring diamonds, emeralds, sapphires, and rubies.

Check out our diamond basics, then take a look at our gemstone jewelry collection, and find all your enduring shine.

Top Tips For Buying Jewelry For Valentine’s Day

  • Find out their style: Different people prefer different styles, so pay attention. Do they always wear yellow gold? Do they stick to diamonds instead of gemstones? And if you’re not sure, go for a classic. The timeless style of these pieces is always a winner.
  • Make it personal: From their birthstone to their zodiac sign, choosing a piece with personal meaning can make any gift extra special.
  • Set a budget: It’s easy to get overwhelmed and stressed out, before you shop, set a budget so you can find a glitzy gift they will love at a price you are comfortable with.
  • Do your research: For example, if you are going for diamonds, it might be time to learn about the 4Cs.

Shop smart: Make sure to shop from a reputable retailer. At James Allen, we pride ourselves on being a trusted online jewelry retailer that offers high-quality jewelry and exceptional customer service.


Does James Allen have free shipping for Valentine’s Day?

Absolutely! We’re happy to offer fast and free worldwide shipping.

Is jewelry a good gift for Valentine’s Day?

Jewelry is always a great gift but on Valentine’s Day, it is extra special.

Is financing available for Valentine’s Day?

Yes, James Allen offers multiple financing options.

Can I get help after hours when shopping for Valentine’s Day?

Our fabulous team of experts in customer service are happy to assist you 24/7.

What should my budget be for a meaningful Valentine’s Day gift?

This is a question that only you can answer, at least the budget part. And it may be cliché, but the best gifts are the ones that come from the heart. Make sure to keep in mind the style of your recipient, and big or small, we have a variety of shining gifts that are sure to make your Valentine’s Day filled with sparkles.

Does James Allen have more extravagant options for higher budgets?

We definitely do! We have a large variety of incredibly luxurious, elegant, and simply fabulous options for those shopping with higher budgets. Whether you want to be dripping in diamonds to find something any royal would be jealous of, we’ve got you covered.

Final Thoughts

Valentine’s Day is a time to celebrate love, romance, friendship, and yourself! Whether you are planning to propose or want to celebrate you, our multiple collections of beautiful jewelry are sure to warm even the biggest cynic’s heart.


+ posts

With over 10 years of experience writing and editing on a wide variety of subjects, Sarah is a veteran of the content world. Since joining James Allen, she has focused on all things diamonds and fine jewelry with the goal of educating and empowering consumers.