Best Diamond Alternatives For Your Engagement Ring

The Best Diamond Alternatives For Your Engagement Ring

Looking for an engagement ring without the traditional diamond center stone? We’re breaking down our list of stunning diamond alternatives for your dream ring!

Gemstones: Best Diamond Alternatives For Your Engagement Ring

What Is A Diamond Alternative?

A substitute for diamonds refers to any gemstone chosen in place of a diamond for an engagement ring or other high-quality jewelry. While many often associate diamond simulants, such as cubic zirconia, with alternatives, there is actually a diverse selection of gemstones that we suggest exploring as unique options for those seeking alternatives to traditional diamonds.

Let’s dive right in!

What Stones Are Comparable To A Diamond?

Moissanite or white sapphire is most comparable to diamonds. There are visible differences between these two gems and diamonds, but they’re the closest gems to resemble diamonds- in both look and fragility.

What Is The Substitute For A Diamond?

Whether you want a gem that looks like a diamond or something totally unique to traditional center stones, we guarantee these diamond alternatives are tough, worth the hype, and every bit as stunning as diamonds.

The Most Popular Diamond Substitute

If you choose to go with a non-diamond gemstone for an engagement ring, two of the most popular options are moissanite and sapphires. Moissanite is a top pick because it resembles diamonds in both look and hardness, but it will guarantee you save a pretty penny! Sapphires are also budget-friendly gems but offer more symbolism and you can choose between many colors.

Most Brilliant Diamond Alternative

Moissanite comes out on top for this option too. If you need to know anything about moissanite, it’s that this gemstone has incredible brilliance and a superior sparkle to diamonds. Moissanite stones come in every shape so you won’t be limited in your options for engagement ring and jewelry styles.

Most Inexpensive Gemstone Center Stone

In general, most gemstones are significantly cheaper than diamonds. The popularity of gemstones does differ, with emeralds, sapphires, and rubies being the most popular, and other gemstones gathering attention from people who associate them with their birth month.

Pros And Cons Of Choosing A Diamond Alternative


  • Your engagement ring will be totally unique
  • Diamond alternatives are typically more cost-effective
  • You have more variety to choose from


  • No gem is as durable as a diamond
  • The perceived value of a diamond is much higher than most gems
  • Most diamond alternatives lack the rarity of natural diamonds

Popular Natural Diamond & Gemstone Alternatives

Let’s take a look at our top selection of diamond alternatives for engagement rings and how they measure up to a natural diamond ring.

Lab Grown Diamonds

Lab grown diamonds aren’t exactly a typical diamond alternative since they’re real diamonds. However, they are a popular option for those who want a real diamond but simply prefer to get more diamonds for their buck.

Remember, if major sparkle and perfect durability are what you’re looking for, a lab diamond is the perfect option for you and your engagement ring budget.

Pear Shaped Lab Grown Diamond


We love moissanite. Why? Simply put, this gem sparkles like no other! This diamond alternative is by far the closest thing to a natural diamond, in appearance and durability. It’s a top choice for engagement ring buyers who want the look of a traditional engagement ring, but not the price tag.

Related Post: Moissanite 101: A Complete Guide

Diamond Engagement Rings


Emerald has a vibrant green color that is sure to make any engagement ring stand out from the crowd. This May birthstone goes perfectly with dark and light metals and offers a unique aesthetic to jewelry pieces.

Notably less durable than sapphires and diamonds, this gem still makes for a fine center stone, available in all shapes and sizes.

Green Emerald Engagement Ring


Did you know that sapphires come in all the colors of the rainbow? This is the September birthstone and one of the most famous gemstones for engagement rings.

With its romantic symbolism, high durability, and endless variety, it really is the perfect choice for a non-traditional engagement ring center stone.

Sapphire and diamond Ring


It’s hard to keep your eyes off of July’s birthstone, ruby, and for good reason. These precious gems showcase a rich red hue that has fascinated civilizations throughout history. Rubies aren’t only a symbol of love but also a representation of strength and courage.

This gem has become a popular choice for those who want a distinctive and meaningful gemstone for engagement rings.

Ruby engagement ring


Pearl engagement rings are a true testament to unique brides everywhere. The June birthstone is by far the most classic gem and makes up one of the few organic gemstones.

Pearls not only come in an array of colors but they have a unique luster and complexity that is sure to make your ring feel as special as your relationship.

Pearl Engagement Ring


October babies know this gem well. We’re talking about the gorgeous pinky peach gem called morganite. Known for its tranquil energy and symbolizing unconditional love, morganite captures the essence of romance and commitment.

With its gentle and warm tones, morganite offers a distinctive alternative to traditional center stones and looks good with all gold metals.

Morganite Ring


Are diamond substitutes more affordable than diamonds?

Yes, in general, diamond alternatives are often more affordable than traditional diamonds.

What ethical and environmental considerations come with choosing a diamond alternative?

The easiest way to know if your chosen gem is ethically sourced is to make sure your jeweler can provide authenticate certificates for your gem before purchase.

How do diamond alternatives compare in terms of durability and sparkle?

It’s true that there is no gem more durable than diamonds, however, many do come close on the Mohs hardness scale and some gems, like moissanite, have a superior sparkle to that of diamonds.


Website | + posts

Jessica is a seasoned content writer with four years of experience and a qualified gemologist. She enjoys educating new shoppers on the best practices for buying jewelry.