buying a fine jewelry gift

The Ultimate Guide for Choosing a Foolproof Jewelry Gift

Choosing a jewelry gift for your partner, made simple.

James Allen's engagement ring

Buying a jewelry gift for your SO can be a stressful and slightly daunting task. We get it. After all, it’s a reminder of the love and commitment you have to each other, and you want to mark the occasion with something special. With so many options out there, you may not know where to begin. Not to worry, follow this guide and you’ll find a foolproof gift in no time.

1. Know Your Partner’s Preferences

First thing’s first. When it comes to a jewelry gift, you should always pay attention to your partner’s particular taste and style. Take notice of what she wears daily. Does she like to glam it up for special occasions? Or does she prefer to keep it straight up classic? These elegant diamond earring options can help you decide.

White Gold Four Prong Diamond Earrings

18K White Gold Four Prong Stud Earrings

White Gold Four Prong Diamond Stud Earrings

2. Decide on a Category

There are many categories of jewelry to choose from. Some good options include earrings, bracelets and necklaces. If your partner’s ears are pierced, go for earrings. If not, then opt for a timeless bracelet or necklace instead. Sometimes it’s good to keep it simple with an all-occasion tennis bracelet or a pair of white gold earrings.

White Gold Four Prong Diamond Tennis Bracelet

14K White Gold Four Prong Diamond Tennis Bracelet

White Gold Inside Out Petite Diamond Hoops

14K White Gold Inside Out Petite Diamond Hoops

3. Choose a Trusted Brand

In general, purchasing your jewelry gift from a reliable brand whose quality you can vouch for is always better, even if it means spending a few bucks more. Remember, good quality doesn’t necessarily mean that you should be spending more! At James Allen, every piece has been carefully inspected by our team of expert gemologists and comes with a lifetime guarantee. So why not get your hands on a pair of beautiful earrings that we cover for life?

Yellow Gold Freshwater Pearl & Diamond Drop Earrings

14K Yellow Gold South Sea Cultured Pearl And Diamond Drop Earrings

Yellow Gold Freshwater Pearl Drop Earrings

14K Yellow Gold Bellflower Cultured Freshwater Pearl Drop Earrings

4. Match the Jewelry Gift to the Occasion

A special occasion calls for a special jewelry gift, agreed? It helps engrain those treasured moments in your memory forever. Whether it’s an anniversary or Valentine’s Day, there’s something for every occasion. Surprise your partner on your next anniversary with an anniversary ring to celebrate another year of love and joy.

White Gold Five Stone Shared Prong Diamond Ring

14K White Gold Five Stone Shared Prong Contour Diamond Ring

White Gold Marquise Ruby & Diamond Pendant

When Valentine’s Day comes around, nail your gift with this necklace, sporting a stunning ruby red gemstone, perfect for romantic occasions.

14K White Gold Marquise Ruby And Diamond Pendant

5. Finally, Make It Personal

Sometimes, you may find that the perfect jewelry gift lies in the little details. Think about engraving a note or your partner’s initials on a beautiful pavé ring. Not only will it make your gift that much more sentimental, but it will also show that you chose the piece especially for her.

White Gold Pavé Knife-Edge Lotus Band

14K White Gold Pave Knife Edge Lotus Band

White Gold Pavé Crossover Wedding Band

14K White Gold Pave Crossover Wedding Band

Starting your gift search? Check out the articles below to get more inspiration!

Bought your jewelry gift? Share the love on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter, Snapchat, or in the comments below!

Drop a hint to your SO with this pin:

Subscribe to our email list for access to secret sales, practical ring-buying tips, and $100 off your first purchase!

+ posts

Jarred is a writer by day and unofficial office ping pong champion