6 Stunning Diamond Alternatives for your Engagement Ring

Looking for a non-diamond engagement ring but not sure which alternative stones are best? We’re here to help!

colored diamonds

When it comes to engagement rings, diamonds are usually the go-to choice. But did you know there are a lot of other stunning alternatives out there that can be just as beautiful and meaningful as a traditional diamond? Here are six gorgeous diamond alternatives for your engagement ring.

What Are The Best Diamond Alternatives For Engagement Rings?


Moissanite is a perfect diamond alternative, known for its incredible brilliance and fire. It’s very durable and comes in various colors, making it a great choice for those seeking a unique and colorful engagement ring.


Sapphires are a classic choice for engagement rings and come in all rainbow colors. From deep blue to pink and even yellow, there are many stunning options to choose from. It’s also the birthstone for September, so if your partner happens to be a September baby, sapphire is an affordable center stone and a personalized choice for their unique engagement ring. 


Opals are one of the most breathtaking diamond alternatives out there and come in an array of milky shades. From the traditional white and black to vibrant blues and greens, there is something for everyone. It’s the birthstone for October and is said to bring luck and symbolizes hope, purity, and truth. 


Emeralds are a popular alternative to diamonds, not only in as the famous shape but because of their stunning green hues. They’re beautiful and durable, making them a great choice for those seeking a non-traditional engagement ring. The best thing about emeralds? They look amazing with most metal colors! 


The March birthstone, aquamarine, is a gorgeous and rare choice for any engagement ring. This oceanic gemstone comes in tones of blues and greens and is perfect for those seeking something a little different and nature-centric. 


Rubies, a classic and luxurious gemstone choice, also tops our list of popular diamond alternatives, and for good reason. July’s birthstone comes in various rich red shades, from deep red to pink and even purple. This timeless gemstone is guaranteed to turn heads paired with any engagement ring. 

No matter what type of diamond alternative you choose for your engagement ring, it’s sure to be beautiful and an extension of your partner’s personal style. From the classic sapphire to magical opals, there are plenty of gorgeous options out there to choose from.

What to Consider Before Buying a Diamond Alternative

Before buying a diamond alternative, it is important to consider the quality of the stone. Some diamond alternatives may look similar to a diamond, but may not be as durable or valuable. 

Additionally, you should consider the cost of the gemstone. Some diamond alternatives can be much less expensive than a real diamond, so it’s essential that your purchase is one of good quality. 

Finally, it is important to consider the overall appearance of your chosen center stone before making a purchase. Most retailers, both in-store and online, will allow you to inspect your stone with a professional. 

Pros And Cons Of Using Diamond Alternatives For Your Engagement Ring

Pros of Diamond Alternatives for Engagement Rings:

  • Affordability: Diamond alternatives can cost significantly less than diamonds, allowing couples to get a larger stone for the same amount as a smaller diamond of the same price range. 
  • Variety: Diamond alternatives come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and colors, which allows couples to find engagement rings that are unique and meaningful to them.
  • Uniqueness: When you buy a gemstone, you immediately invest in a personalized and non-traditional engagement ring. 

Cons of Diamond Alternatives for Engagement Rings:

  • Durability: Diamonds are known for their strength and durability, which makes them a popular choice for engagement rings. Diamond alternatives may not be as durable, making them more prone to damage over time.
  • Quality: Diamonds are the highest quality gemstone available, and many diamond alternatives may not have the same level of quality.
  • Resale Value: Diamonds tend to retain their value over time, making them a good investment. Diamond alternatives may not have the same level of resale value.


Are gemstone engagement rings more affordable than diamond engagement rings? 

Yes, gemstone engagement rings can be more affordable than diamond engagement rings. Gemstone rings often feature colored stones like sapphires or rubies, which tend to cost less than diamonds. Additionally, gemstone rings often have smaller stones and more intricate settings, which can also help to reduce the overall cost.

What is the best alternative to a diamond? 

A moissanite is the best alternative to a diamond, as most are lab created stones with a similar look and sparkle to a diamond but are much more affordable.

What looks like a diamond but is cheaper?

 Moissanite is a gemstone that looks similar to a diamond but is much less expensive.

Is it ok to get a non-diamond engagement ring?

Yes, it is perfectly acceptable to get a non-diamond engagement ring. In fact, many couples choose to forego diamonds in favor of more unique options such as colored gemstones, moissanite, or even custom-made pieces. It is ultimately up to the couple to decide what is right for them.

Happy Ring Shopping

Overall, shopping for a diamond alternative engagement ring is a great option for couples who are looking for an affordable and stunning ring.

With a wide range of options, including our top 6 alternatives, the selection of styles and prices at JamesAllen.com makes it easy to find the perfect ring for any budget. Plus, our commitment to customer service and quality assurance ensures that you are getting the best possible ring for your special day.

Subscribe to our email list for access to secret sales, practical ring-buying tips, and $100 off your first purchase!

The author generated this text in part with GPT-3. The author reviewed, edited, and revised the language and takes ultimate responsibility for the content.

Website | + posts

Jessica feels too much anxiety trying to come up with a cool bio. Read her awesome blog post instead.